All Sections

View and post jobs in journalism
  • Platforms
  • Publishers
  • Comment/Analysis
  • Editor's Pick
  • Interviews
  • News
    • Broadcast Journalism
    • Digital Journalism
    • Magazines
    • Media Law
    • National Newspapers
    • People
      • Appointments
      • Obituaries
    • Regional Newspapers
  • Press Gazette Podcast
  • British Journalism Awards
  • Press Gazette Email Newsletter

In the news

  • Platforms
  • Publishers
  • Interviews
  • Marketing
  • About us
  • Privacy Policy
  • Contact
  • Advertise
  • RSS
Close
[mashshare]
Skip to content
  • About us
  • Privacy Policy
  • Contact
  • Advertise
  • RSS
All sections

Search

Search pressgazette.co.uk

Close

Press Gazette

Subscribe to our email newsletter Journalism email newsletter
  • News
  • Comment
  • Data
  • Platforms
  • Publishers
  • Marketing
  • Awards
  • Jobs

Menu

  • Platforms
  • Publishers
  • Interviews
  • National Newspapers
  • Regional Newspapers
  • Digital Journalism
  • Broadcast Journalism
  • Media Law
  • Magazines
  • Wires and Agencies
  • Obituaries
  • News
  • Comment/Analysis
  • Jobs
  • British Journalism Awards

In the news

  • Platforms
  • Publishers
  • Interviews
  • Marketing
Close
Newsgathering abroad is not among essential work exempt from 14-day quarantine restrictions says Home Office
most popular newspapers UK Journalism after Covid-19: 'It's not an extinction-level event'
June 11, 2020
  • Digital Journalism
  •    
  • Media Law
  •    
  • National Newspapers
  •    
  • News
  •    
  • Social media
  •    

IPSO: Telegraph OK to use one tweet from science editor to back claim BBC wants UK to adopt plant-based diet

By Charlotte Tobitt Twitter

Share this

  • Tweet
  • Share 0
  • Reddit
Comments
0
BBC Broadcasting House

A tweet by a BBC journalist was enough to allow a newspaper to claim the broadcaster had misrepresented research on vegan and vegetarian diets, press regulator IPSO has ruled.

A Sunday Telegraph column published in August last year claimed that by “misreporting” UN research, the BBC “wants us to switch to a mostly plant-based diet in order to alter the weather”.

Timeline

  • January 14, 2021

    New BBC chairman says Brexit coverage was 'incredibly balanced' and calls licence fee 'least worst' option

  • January 11, 2021

    Journalists must be 'activists for impartiality' to rebuild trust in media - BBC’s Tim Davie

  • January 7, 2021

    New Journalist of the Year Rianna Croxford on how she became BBC's youngest network news correspondent

This claim was based only on a tweet by the BBC’s science editor David Shukman, who shared a link to a colleague’s story on the research and added: “Switching to a plant-based diet can help tackle climate change.”

The Sunday Telegraph later received a complaint that its column was wrong because the BBC’s reporting had been accurate.

But the newspaper told IPSO that several other parties had interpreted Shukman’s tweet as being incorrect “for not acknowledging that the UN report did not recommend a solely plant-based diet”.

Switching to a plant-based diet can help tackle climate change – UN study by @IPCC_CH⁩ reported by ⁦@RHarrabin⁩ https://t.co/sJAlakjICj

— David Shukman (@davidshukmanbbc) August 8, 2019

IPSO backed the Telegraph, saying Shukman, whose Twitter handle is @davidshukmanbbc, had tweeted “seemingly in his official capacity” and that it therefore was not misleading to refer to the BBC rather than him by name.

“The UN report had acknowledged the benefits to the environment of a balanced diet of both plant and animal-based products,” IPSO said in its ruling.

“In these circumstances, it was not misleading for the columnist to have claimed that the BBC, by virtue of the tweet, had misrepresented the report.”

But IPSO did rule against the Sunday Telegraph on another point. The newspaper had referred to a meta-analysis of peer-reviewed papers which it claimed had made a finding relating to “the average westerner”.

It was pointed out that the relevant studies were undertaken only in the UK, Germany, the Netherlands and India, and IPSO said this moniker was therefore misleading in breach of Clause 1 (accuracy) of the Editors’ Code of Practice.

“As the article referenced the research to support its position on the environmental impact of giving up meat, the territorial scope of the research was significant, and the description needed to be corrected,” IPSO said.

The BBC formalised some of its social media guidance for staff last year, warning them that “BBC staff should avoid bringing the BBC into disrepute through their actions on social media”.

The guidance added that staff must “take particular care” to maintain the BBC’s impartiality online in both their professional and personal activities.

Read the full IPSO ruling here.

Picture: Reuters/Peter Nicholls

SIGN UP HERE FOR

MEDIA MONITOR

Press Gazette's weekly email providing strategic insight into the future of the media

Subscribe

Related Stories

  • Press regulator to issue new guidance on stories about Islam or Muslims that ‘will not impinge right to criticise or challenge’
  • The Express was a repeat offender when it came to misleading press coverage ahead of UK 's vote to leave the European Union
  • External review of IPSO finds press regulator is independent, effective and largely compliant with Leveson
  • IPSO third-party complaints on climate change 'empower bullies and curb press freedom'

Explore these topics

  • BBC
  • IPSO rulings
  • The Sunday Telegraph
  • The Telegraph
Browse, search and add journalism jobs
Comments
No comments to display

Leave a Reply Cancel reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

More content

Post a job on Press Gazette

Most Popular

  1. cookies Enter Sandbox: How Google is building an internet without cookies - and why publishers are concerned
  2. Washington Post plans to grow newsroom to record size (1,000+ journalists) in 2021 after hitting digital ad and subscription peaks
  3. Independent TV launches as title reports revenue up 23% year on year
  4. PA wins High Court injunction against union issuing 'fake' press passes to 'citizen journalists'
  5. The Times Lucy Fisher On the Record: Times defence correspondent Lucy Fisher - 'Working in news is the best job in the world'

Latest Jobs

  • Editor in Chief, Scottish Sun
  • Features Producer, Economist Radio
Twitter is on fire and journalists should try not to fan the flames

© copyright 2021 Press Gazette Ltd. Made in Taiwan.