View all newsletters
Sign up for our free email newsletters

Fighting for quality news media in the digital age.

  1. Archive content
July 24, 2003updated 22 Nov 2022 1:17pm

Pre-season victory for Premiership

By Press Gazette

The football season is almost upon us. For some it’s a moment of despair as football takes over again. Among that number is Panini, seller of collectable stickers of Premiership footballers.

Earlier this month, the Court of Appeal handed down its unanimous 3-0 judgment in favour of the Premiership, its clubs and Topps, the producer of the official Premiership sticker collection, in their claim that Panini had infringed their copyright in the club badges and the Premiership emblem (“the logos”).

Nearly all the players pictured in the Panini 2002-03 season collection wore their side’s strip bearing the logos. Panini claimed that the logos were merely incidental inclusion of one copyright work in another. The judge at first instance found the inclusion of the logos was integral to the depiction of the players in their current strip.

The court said the word “incidental” needed no special definition and the court should apply its ordinary meaning in the particular circumstances. In Panini’s case, it was irrelevant what the photographer had in mind when he took the pictures. What was key was the circumstances in which the pictures (which were artistic works) were created. The photos were to be used in a sticker album with the idea of being attractive to collectors. To be attractive, the players had to appear in their teams’ strips and the strips had to be authentic. To be authentic, the club badge and the emblem had to be included. The use of the logos was not therefore incidental.

Off his own bat, one of the Court of Appeal judges went further and aired the opinion that the sticker albums were not artistic works, but compilations. If right, this meant they would be treated as literary works and therefore Panini would not even be entitled to argue that the logos were incidental. The Premiership’s lawyers declined to take up this suggestion, possibly concerned what affect it might have on protecting the official collection.

The Panini judgment might cause sports editors to believe their investment and innovation in previewing the forthcoming season are now wasted. Wait a second before pressing the “delete” button. Most previews will be editorial in nature, whether sponsored or not. They are unlikely to be in competition with the Premiership or clubs, in contrast to Panini. They are also unlikely to be collectables. Many photos will be action shots in which the logos may be obscured.

Content from our partners
MHP Group's 30 To Watch awards for young journalists open for entries
How PA Media is helping newspapers make the digital transition
Publishing on the open web is broken, how generative AI could help fix it

Ultimately, while football clubs, and in particular Premiership clubs, have sought in recent years to exert control over the copyright in photos taken inside their grounds, commercial reality must bite at some point.

It is one thing to pursue Panini, a commercial rival; it is another thing to cut off the oxygen supply the press gives the sport. Encouraging the press to airbrush club badges and sponsors’ names is no way for a sport to attract desperately needed sponsorship revenue. The Panini judgment does mean exercising greater care than perhaps might have been the case before, but there is no need to scrap the previews just yet.

Julian Pike is a partner with Farrer and Co

Email pged@pressgazette.co.uk to point out mistakes, provide story tips or send in a letter for publication on our "Letters Page" blog

Select and enter your email address Weekly insight into the big strategic issues affecting the future of the news industry. Essential reading for media leaders every Thursday. Your morning brew of news about the world of news from Press Gazette and elsewhere in the media. Sent at around 10am UK time. Our weekly does of strategic insight about the future of news media aimed at US readers. A fortnightly update from the front-line of news and advertising. Aimed at marketers and those involved in the advertising industry.
  • Business owner/co-owner
  • CEO
  • COO
  • CFO
  • CTO
  • Chairperson
  • Non-Exec Director
  • Other C-Suite
  • Managing Director
  • President/Partner
  • Senior Executive/SVP or Corporate VP or equivalent
  • Director or equivalent
  • Group or Senior Manager
  • Head of Department/Function
  • Manager
  • Non-manager
  • Retired
  • Other
Visit our privacy Policy for more information about our services, how New Statesman Media Group may use, process and share your personal data, including information on your rights in respect of your personal data and how you can unsubscribe from future marketing communications.
Thank you

Thanks for subscribing.

Websites in our network